Pleasant City, Ohio lies in the hilly terrain of the Appalachian Mountains. The small town is located in Guernsey County, Ohio and is part of Valley Township the town was originally named Point Pleasant. Valley Township was founded in 1815 and the small town of Point Pleasant was founded in 1829. Before the town’s settlement the area was home to many different tribes of Native Americans, but after the formation of the Virginia Military white settlers came to the area in droves and pushed out the Natives. The town was founded mainly by French settlers and also a large number of Virginians who came from Irish and German decent. The town prospered during the age of the coal boom and the height of the reliance of railroads in the 1800’s. The town held steady into the 1950’s economically and then seen a rapid decline of economic activity after the 1960’s. The town currently has a population below 500 and there are not many businesses to be found in and around the city.
The hilly town of modern day Pleasant City was founded in 1829. The region offered fertile farmland for settlers and also had a source of power for mills with Will’s Creek nearby. Agriculture proved to be the main stable of Pleasant City’s economy up until the coal boom in the late 1800’s. The main part of the city was placed in a basin that is surrounded by hills and Will’s Creek. The historic core of the small town formerly known as Point Pleasant is still visible in the town today. The early settlers that originally came to the area traveled from Virginia mainly and also many settlers of the area came from France. The remnants of these early settlers are clearly visible in the town’s historic churches. The town features a Methodist for settlers with Irish descent who came from Virginia, a Catholic church for the Eastern European Catholics who migrated to the area during the coal boom, and finally two Lutheran churches for the German settlers. These settlers mainly farmed the area and made their living by doing so. The town then drastically changed in the later part of the 1800’s as the railroad boomed in the area and the local coal industry took off.
Pleasant City itself does not have rich natural resources, but nearby small towns in the area did. The small towns of Cumberland, Kipling, Derwent, and Walhonding all had sizeable coal mines with Cumberland having the largest deposit. The proximity of the coal industry to Pleasant City greatly impacted the economy of the small town and saw an influx of foreigners to the area. People from Eastern Europe flocked to the area in droves as the nearby coal industry spread. This caused significant changes in the city as more buildings became built to help accommodate the new workers. This also led to the construct of St. Michael’s Byzantine Church to help the new peoples find a place to worship. The coal boom in combination with the railroads saw the town move away from agriculture as farmers sought more profitable work in mines versus the daily toil of their land. Pleasant City reached the height of its prosperity as the ninetieth century came to pass thanks to the coal boom. The economy of the area remained steady until the end of the 1950’s and the population of the town remained steady. New industries appeared nearby and in the city itself. In nearby Ava a vital brickyard appeared, saw mills opened in nearby Chaseville, and the town even gained its own pop bottling company. The town in the late 1950’s had a bakery, laundromat, bank, bottling company, and many restaurants. The focus on farming further dissipated as the automobile became commonplace in the 1930’s and allowed workers to travel greater distances for new jobs. This prosperity came to a screeching halt as Interstate 70 became completed in the late 1960’s in the area.
The construction of the highway system by the United States Government tore apart farms and harmed the rail industry. This coupled with the closing of coal mines around the area and the eventually closing of the Ava brickyard spelled doom for the small Appalachian town of Pleasant City. The Interstate divided farms and tore apart families in the area near Pleasant city. The lesser impact of the railroad harmed key industries around the city and saw many of them close their doors by the 1970’s. The town lost many of its shops and saw its population began to dip below 500 citizens. Key roads were destroyed that led to the sawmills in Chaseville by the Interstate and in the 1960’s the school in Pleasant City closed its doors as the area students became integrated into the newly formed schools of Meadowbrook and Shenandoah. The town still has yet to recover from these disastrous times. The town currently has around only 400 people in it and has only one seasonal restaurant compared to the multiple ones it possessed over 50 years ago. The main reasons why this rapid decline occurred are the negative impacts that the Interstate had on the area, the closing of key nearby industries, and the movement away from agriculture in the area.
In conclusion, the best days are behind the small town of Pleasant City and there does not appear to be many solutions to help the small town grow again except for one realistic possibility. The moving of local industries overseas and to other regions of America has crushed Pleasant City and Guernsey County as a whole. This does not mean that as a resident of Pleasant that I am not proud of our past, but I hope that possibly a second oil boom occurs and this helps the small towns as it did in 2014, but only for a very short time. If the oil jobs come back in droves the small town can acquire funds to help it grow again. I am concerned for the future of my small town, but I will always have hope that we can turn it around and regain our lost prosperity.
Photos taken by Brett Lenarz
Sources: Colonel Cyrus P.B. Sarchet, History of Guernsey County, B.F. Brown & Company, Indianapolis, IN.